Insights

Who is zone based carsharing right for?

Between fixed stations and free floating sits a third model: the zone. When it is the better choice – and what matters when drawing it.

Roland Kainbacher – Porträt Roland Kainbacher 7 min
Illustration: Zonenbasiertes Carsharing

In station based carsharing every vehicle has a fixed parking space: that is where it is picked up and where it must be returned. In the free floating model the car sits somewhere in the city and may be left anywhere. Zone based carsharing sits in between – and for many operators it is the more practical route.

What a zone is

A zone is a defined area within which a vehicle may be picked up and parked again. That can be a district, a town centre, a company site or an entire municipality. Within the zone users are free: they park where there is space instead of having to reach one particular bay.

Unlike free floating, however, the trip does not end just anywhere. Anyone parking outside the zone cannot close the booking – or pays a surcharge, depending on how you set it up.

The difference in practice

The decisive point is predictability. With free floating you do not know where your vehicles will be tomorrow morning – you need a team to redistribute them. With stations you know exactly, but you have to rent and sign parking spaces, and your customers have to make their way there.

The zone combines both: you know the area your fleet moves in without paying for a reserved space per vehicle. On top of that, bookings for future dates become possible – something purely spontaneous free floating can hardly offer, because nobody can guarantee a vehicle nearby in three days' time.

Who the model suits

  • Municipalities and small towns. The town centre as a zone: users pick the vehicle up at the market square, the station or in front of the town hall – without you running three separate stations.
  • Neighbourhoods and housing projects. The zone covers the site. Residents park in the underground garage or on one of the visitor spaces, whichever is free.
  • Company sites and campuses. Company vehicles may be parked anywhere on the premises but do not leave them unchecked.
  • Regions with several towns. Several zones side by side, one per municipality – with the rule that vehicles are returned to their home zone.
  • Tourist regions. Guests move within the town, the vehicle stays in the region.

When stations are the better choice

Zones are not always right. Where charging infrastructure is involved, fixed spaces make sense: an electric car parked somewhere in the zone is not charging. The same applies where parking is scarce – a reserved bay is often the only way to keep a vehicle reliably available.

With very small fleets a station can also be simpler: with two vehicles in one place, a fixed spot is easier to grasp than an area rule.

What to watch when drawing the zone

  • Not too large. The bigger the zone, the longer the walk to the vehicle can become. What looks compact on a map is quickly twenty minutes on foot.
  • Follow real boundaries. Rivers, railway lines and main roads are easier to grasp than an arbitrary line through a residential area.
  • Clarify parking rules. Traffic regulations still apply inside the zone. State clearly whether resident bays, short-stay zones or private ground are allowed.
  • Define returns outside the zone. Either you prevent closing the booking or you allow it for a fee – but decide, and put it in your terms of use.

Both at the same time is possible

In practice many operators mix the models. One vehicle at the station with a fixed bay, three more free within the town zone; or a zone for everyday use and stations where charging happens. In Zemtu this is defined per vehicle – same fleet, same app, different rules.

If you are unsure which model fits your location: start smaller. A zone can be enlarged later without anyone having to relearn anything. The opposite – shrinking an area people have got used to – causes friction.